Calgary resident Lee Antoni returned home to a horrific scene in 2015, discovering his wife, Amanda, dead in their basement. The episode “Body in the Basement” from Unsolved Mysteries Volume 4 delves into the mysterious circumstances surrounding Amanda’s death. Initial suspicions fell on Lee, but an alibi placing him in another province raised more questions.

Amanda Antoni, a beloved individual known for her kind heart and playful nature, met Lee in her 20s, leading to their marriage in 2009. Despite occasional struggles, the couple shared a close bond. Amanda’s sudden death left lingering questions, with investigators exploring various theories, including a potential intruder or a tragic accident.

As details emerged, the case grew more perplexing. Amanda’s autopsy revealed blunt force trauma as the cause of death, but with no signs of forced entry and only her DNA at the scene, intruder theories lost traction. Her family, unconvinced by the accident theory, pointed to peculiar details like an overturned chair and the dog’s behavior.
Forensic analysis, including bloodstain pattern investigations, added layers of complexity to the case. The presence of bloody footprints at the base of the stairs, facing upward, raised questions about the sequence of events leading to Amanda’s death. Friends and family shared memories of Amanda’s vibrant personality, while investigators grappled with the lack of conclusive evidence.
The neighborhood’s crime statistics and witness testimonies further muddied the waters, suggesting potential external involvement in Amanda’s demise. Despite extensive investigations, unanswered questions and puzzling evidence left the case of Amanda Antoni unresolved, haunting her loved ones and investigators alike.

Unsolved Mysteries Volume 4 sheds light on the enigmatic circumstances surrounding Amanda’s death, highlighting the challenges of piecing together a complex and ambiguous case. As the search for answers continues, the legacy of Amanda Antoni endures, a poignant reminder of the enduring impact of unsolved mysteries.
🔗 Reddit Discussions
- I found the bunker of a prepper family who went missing three years ago
- I’ve been getting caught up on the Netflix remake of Unsolved Mysteries recently, and there are a couple cases (that are new to me, at least) that I’d love to hear people’s thoughts about.
- I love my wife, but I had sex with her sister.